Peter Reynolds

The life and times of Peter Reynolds

The Third Milliband Brother?

with 5 comments

James Brokenshire

I have very mixed feelings about young James Brokenshire.  He’s a Tory and so am I, so I don’t really want to be too derogatory about him.   It’s very difficult though, just  keeping a straight face, let alone seeing anything positive.  Most difficult of all to ignore is the Milliband in him.  I mean, come on, tell me I’m wrong!

One of my more erudite commenters mentioned the phenomenon of Nominative Determinism.  According to Wikipedia:

Nominative determinism refers to the theory that a person’s name is given an influential role in reflecting key attributes of his job, profession, or general life. It was a commonly held philosophy in the ancient world.

It’s not just that he looks like a Milliband.  It goes much deeper than that.  Alright, so George Osborne is right in there as well and I just know I’ve seen at least a dozen other clones.  I just can’t quite remember their names or distinguish them.  They’re the generation that’s heir to Cameron and Clegg.  They’ve gone from graduate to researcher, never had a real job, eternally trapped within the political bubble. You know the type.  And yes, our politics and our society are broken, broken because of the sort of policies, attitudes and behaviour that James exhibits.

Of course, I’m on the libertarian side of the party and James is way, way opposite.   He comes across as not just a hanger and flogger but a hanger, drawer and quarterer – and that’s just for parking tickets.   The trouble is, I fear he’s making such an twit of himself that he’s doing my party a grave disservice.   For such a young and youngish man he is a very old, very old reactionary Tory.

James is the new Minister of State for Crime Prevention.  Congratulations to him on his appointment at such an early stage in his career.  What an important job!  He does rather bring to mind all those old jokes about policemen looking like they should still be in short trousers.   Does anyone take him seriously?

He’s the government’s front man for the drugs issue.  That’s right, it’s not a minister from the Department of Health who deals with drugs.  It’s the Home Office!  Anyway, even before the current furore, I’d seen James in action in reply to a question about drugs policy.   He’s authoritarian, repressive, intransigent and far, far too sure of himself even when he doesn’t know what he’s talking about.  This is not someone who believes in “small” government.   Like the Millibands and other illiberal socialists he wants close control of our lives.  I’m sorry but the boy looks silly and he behaves like an idiot.  He’s being taken to pieces all over the internet – ridiculed, abused and condemned.  David Cameron, please get rid of him now!

The trouble is that James is trying to come over all tough and spunky but he doesn’t realise that even men of my sons’ ages have seen it all before.  Eager young politicians who think they know best when they know nothing have been making similar fools of themselves since time began.  To coin a counterfeit phrase,  I’d smoked more joints than he’s had hot dinners before there was even a twinkle in his daddy’s eye!  So many of us had thought through and argued out the drugs issue a hundred times before James even left nursery school.

I can’t really expect a replacement who agrees with me 100% on drugs policy.   What I do expect is someone who is credible, sensible, well informed and committed to evidence-based policy and truth.  James is none of these.  He is making a fool of the government.

What’s really serious is that the man is misguided.  He’s flying in the face of the facts and all the experts.  Drugs policy has huge impact on our society and we need to move away from our present disastrous and oppressive course.  James Brokenshire is the wrong man for the job.

5 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. What’s the point in descending to this kind of personal abuse?

    It usually means that you have lost the arguement on its merits.

    John Bull

    August 24, 2010 at 12:32 am

    • I don’t think there’s any chance of that! No, the man is making a fool of himself. He doesn’t need my help. It’s not funny really because his job has a serious impact on people’s lives. I’m just using humour to bring attention to something very serious that needs to be changed. It’s not abusive. The man is seriously dangerous and needs to be stopped by any means within the law.

      Peter Reynolds

      August 24, 2010 at 12:39 am

  2. You forget that nearly all politicians spout the same tired mantra when it comes to drugs policy (with a few notable exceptions: Mo Mowlam, Lembit Opik etc) Without leadership they revert to type and shelter themselves behind the safe, warm, blanket of prohibitionist semantics. Here they are safe in the knowledge they won’t upset the status quo, at the same time appeasing the ignorant middle classes who fail to see the hypocrisy and damage of the current situation; who see the current situation as a symptom of not being ‘tough enough’. It is a slippery, dangerous slope and MUST be stopped.

    We desperately need leadership on this issue, and I naively thought we might have actually some from Cameron and Clegg on this issue given they have supported rethinking of drug policy in the past. As you say, Brokenshire’s tired comments are laughable to someone with half a brain. But hey – he’s got a face that says: ‘drugs are bad mmmmkay’ (and the right sort of name too).


    August 24, 2010 at 2:35 am

    • No Olly, I haven’t forgotten that. How could I? Our cowardly politicians have failed to grasp this nettle for years and are personally responsible for much of the misery, death and degradation caused by drugs and drug laws. Brokenshire is a very dangerous young fool with a complete absence of knowledge or understanding. He needs to be stopped.

      Peter Reynolds

      August 24, 2010 at 7:52 am

  3. […] The Third Milliband Brother? […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: